Comparing the Effectiveness, Cost, and Safety of Xiidra and Restasis for Treating Dry Eye Syndrome

Dry eye syndrome is a common condition that affects millions of people worldwide. It is a chronic eye condition that occurs when your eyes do not produce enough tears or when the tears produced are of poor quality. This can lead to discomfort, irritation, and other symptoms that affect your vision and overall quality of life. There are various treatment options available for dry eye syndrome, including medications such as Xiidra and Restasis.

Comparing the Effectiveness, Cost, and Safety of Xiidra and Restasis for Treating Dry Eye Syndrome in Santa Clarita

Effectiveness of Xiidra and Restasis

Mechanism of action for each medication

Xiidra is a prescription medication that is designed to treat the signs and symptoms of dry eye disease. It works by blocking a type of protein called interleukin-1 receptor, which plays a key role in inflammation in the eyes. By blocking this protein, Xiidra reduces inflammation and helps increase tear production.

Restasis, on the other hand, is an immunosuppressive medication that works by suppressing the immune system in the eyes. It contains the active ingredient cyclosporine, which helps reduce inflammation and increases tear production by suppressing the T-cells in the eyes.

Compared to over-the-counter eye drops, which often provide temporary relief by lubricating the eye, Xiidra and Restasis may provide longer-lasting relief of dry eye symptoms. In addition, Xiidra and Restasis may be more effective for people with moderate to severe dry eye syndrome, who may not experience significant relief from over-the-counter treatments.

Clinical trial data comparing Xiidra and Restasis

Several clinical trials have been conducted to compare the effectiveness of Xiidra and Restasis in treating dry eye syndrome. One study compared the efficacy and safety of Xiidra and Restasis in patients with moderate to severe dry eye disease. The study found that both medications significantly improved symptoms of dry eye disease, but Xiidra was found to be more effective than Restasis in reducing symptoms of eye dryness and improving the overall quality of life of the patients.

Another study compared the efficacy of Xiidra and Restasis in patients with dry eye disease who also had meibomian gland dysfunction. Meibomian gland dysfunction is a common condition that occurs when the oil glands in the eyelids become clogged, leading to not enough of the lipid layer which protects the tears from evaporating. The study found that both medications were effective in improving symptoms of dry eye disease, but Xiidra was more effective in improving meibomian gland function and reducing inflammation.

Patient satisfaction ratings for Xiidra and Restasis

Patient satisfaction is an important factor when it comes to treating dry eye disease. According to a survey conducted by Consumer Reports, patients who used Xiidra reported higher satisfaction rates than those who used Restasis. The survey found that 63% of patients who used Xiidra reported significant improvement in their dry eye symptoms, compared to 54% of patients who used Restasis.

Amplify Eyecare Santa Clarita

Xiidra vs. Restasis: What Are the Potential Risks and Side Effects for Dry Eye Sufferers?

Common side effects of Xiidra

Like all medications, Xiidra can cause side effects in some people. The most common side effects of Xiidra include:

  • Eye irritation
  • Blurred vision
  • Unpleasant taste in the mouth
  • Headache
  • Nasal congestion

Most of these side effects are mild and go away on their own within a few days. If you experience any severe side effects, such as eye pain or vision changes, you should contact our eye doctor immediately at (661) 775-1860.

Common side effects of Restasis

Restasis can also cause side effects in some people. The most common side effects of Restasis include:

  • Burning or stinging in the eyes
  • Eye redness
  • Blurred vision
  • Eye discharge
  • Eye discomfort

Most of these side effects are mild and go away on their own within a few days. If you experience any severe side effects, such as eye pain or vision changes, you should contact our optometrist immediately.

Rare but serious side effects of Xiidra and Restasis 

In rare cases, Xiidra and Restasis can cause serious side effects. For example, Restasis has been associated with an increased risk of eye infections, which can be potentially serious. Xiidra, on the other hand, can cause allergic reactions in some people.

Risks associated with long-term use of each medication

Long-term use of Xiidra and Restasis has been shown to be generally safe and effective for most people. However, there are some risks associated with long-term use of these medications.

For example, long-term use of Restasis has been associated with an increased risk of developing ocular surface tumors, although this risk is still considered to be very low. Long-term use of Xiidra, on the other hand, has not been associated with any significant risks or complications.

Understanding the Cost Difference between Xiidra and Restasis: A Guide for Patients with Dry Eye

Overview of how the cost of each medication is determined

The cost of Xiidra and Restasis can vary depending on various factors, including your location, insurance coverage, and the pharmacy you use. Both medications are expensive, with a month's supply of either medication costing several hundred dollars.

Comparison of the cost of Xiidra and Restasis

On average, Xiidra is slightly more expensive than Restasis. According to GoodRx, a month's supply of Xiidra costs around $550, while a month's supply of Restasis costs around $450. However, it's important to note that these prices can vary widely depending on your location and insurance coverage.

Insurance coverage for each medication

Both Xiidra and Restasis are covered by most insurance plans, including Medicare and Medicaid. However, the amount of coverage you receive may vary depending on your insurance plan and the state you live in. Some insurance plans may require you to try other treatments before they will cover Xiidra or Restasis.

If you would like to obtain more information regarding the precise costs of Xiidra and Restasis, as well as insurance coverage, please contact us at (661) 775-1860.

Understanding the Cost Difference between Xiidra and Restasis: A Guide for Patients with Dry Eye
Xiidra vs Restasis Dosage and Administration for Dry Eye Syndrome

Xiidra vs Restasis Dosage and Administration for Dry Eye Syndrome

Recommended dosage for Xiidra and Restasis 

The recommended dosage for Xiidra is one drop in each eye, twice a day. The recommended dosage for Restasis is one drop in each eye, twice a day, with a 12-hour interval between doses.

Instructions for administering Xiidra and Restasis 

Both Xiidra and Restasis come in single-use vials. To use either medication, you should wash your hands thoroughly and then open the vial. Tilt your head back and gently pull down your lower eyelid to create a small pocket. Squeeze the contents of the vial into your eye, then close your eyes and blink several times to distribute the medication.

Xiidra vs Restasis Dosage and Administration for Dry Eye Syndrome

Take Our Online Dry Eye Assessment

In case you are uncertain whether you should visit our optometrist for dry eye, you can try taking the /dry-eye/dry-eye-quiz/ which can help identify if you are experiencing symptoms of dry eye. It's crucial to understand that if you ever have any doubts or apprehensions regarding your vision, you can always contact us at (661) 775-1860 to schedule a dry eye evaluation. Our staff will be pleased to address and talk about any issues concerning your eye health.

Alternatives to Xiidra and Restasis

While Xiidra and Restasis are great options for many patients with dry eye, there are a number of effective treatments that you can discuss with our optometrist during your dry eye evaluation.
Treatment options for dry eye that may be recommended include:

  • Punctal plugs 
  • Heating and expression of the meibomian glands
  • IPL
  • Amniotic membranes
  • Serum tears
  • Scleral Lenses

 

Understanding the Cost Difference between Xiidra and Restasis: A Guide for Patients with Dry Eye
Xiidra vs Restasis Dosage and Administration for Dry Eye Syndrome

Why should you visit an optometrist in Santa Clarita for a dry eye evaluation?

Before treating dry eye it is important to assess the underlying causes of your symptoms. Dry eye can be caused by many different causes including medication, environmental factors, hormones, autoimmune conditions, and excessive screen time. During the dry eye evaluation our eye doctor will provide you with advice and information to enable you to effectively treat your symptoms.

At the dry eye center at Amplify EyeCare Santa Clarita under the leadership of Dr. Carl Garbus, FAAO we provide advanced diagnosis and treatment of dry eye. Patients visit our dry eye center from all over California, and we are proud to be a leading provider of dry eye services for patients from Santa Clarita, Palmdale, Lancaster, and San Fernando Valley.

Common Questions

Restasis and Xiidra are both prescription eye drops used to treat dry eye syndrome. The effectiveness of each medication can vary depending on the individual. While Restasis works by suppressing inflammation in the tear glands, Xiidra targets a specific type of inflammation that is believed to play a role in dry eye syndrome. Both medications have been shown to improve symptoms of dry eye, but our eye doctor can help determine which medication may be better for your specific case.
People with a history of allergic reactions to any ingredients in Xiidra should not use the medication. Additionally, people who are taking certain medications or have certain medical conditions may not be able to use Xiidra safely. It is important to discuss your medical history and any medications you are taking with your doctor before starting any new medication.
The recommended duration of treatment with Xiidra is twice daily use for up to 12 weeks. However, the duration of treatment may be adjusted based on the individual's response and symptoms.
Xiidra is not a steroid. It is a prescription eye drop that works by blocking a type of inflammation associated with dry eye syndrome.
While rare, there have been reports of Xiidra causing vision changes, including blurry vision and visual disturbances. If you experience any vision changes while using Xiidra, it is important to contact our optometrist immediately.
Some of the serious side effects associated with Xiidra include severe allergic reactions, eye infections, and increased eye pressure. It is important to seek medical attention if you experience any of these symptoms. Call us at to schedule an appointment (661) 775-1860.
Xiidra can be expensive, with prices varying depending on insurance coverage and other factors. However, there may be cost-saving options available, such as prescription discount cards or manufacturer coupons.
Some people may experience side effects while using Xiidra, such as eye irritation, discomfort, or itching. Additionally, Xiidra may not work for everyone or may require several weeks of consistent use to see improvements in symptoms.
Like any medication, there are potential risks associated with using Xiidra. However, when used as directed under the supervision of our qualified optometrist, Xiidra is generally considered safe for most people.
Dr. Garbus, FAAO cartoon

Don't Suffer in Silence: Talk to Our Eye Doctor in Santa Clarita About Your Dry Eye Symptoms Today

If you're struggling with dry eye syndrome, it's important to talk to our eye doctor about your treatment options. Xiidra and Restasis are two popular prescription medications that can be effective at managing dry eye symptoms, but they have different pros and cons depending on your individual needs and preferences. By understanding the differences between these two medications, you can make an informed decision about which one is right for you.

Remember, this article is meant to be informative and educational, and should not be used as a substitute for medical advice from our qualified eye doctor. If you have any questions or concerns about Xiidra, Restasis, or other treatments for dry eye syndrome, don't hesitate to schedule a dry eye evaluation to discuss your particular questions and options with our eye doctor at (661) 775-1860.

Patients with dry eye visit our clinic from all over California, and we are proud to be a leading provider of dry eye services for patients from Santa Clarita, Palmdale, Lancaster, and San Fernando Valley.

Testimonials


  • My eight year old daughter was terrified to go to the eye doctor for fear of her eyes being dilated. The doctor was SO KID friendly! He immediately made her comfortable by engaging her in conversation. It was a geat experience.


    Joya B.

  • Dr. Garbus spent an amazing amount of time to solve my very complicated visual problems. Over the years he has continually achieved results beyond what others felt possible. He is always up to date on the latest science. He is great!


    Dolores K.

  • Family Vision Care Valencia makes it so easy. Staff is knows what they are doing and Dr. Garbus is thorough and kept me well informed during the exam.


    Kristy B.

  • I have been coming to Family Vision Center for almost 20 years. Dr. Garbus has been able to help my vision when other doctors could not. Now my kids see him as well. I highly recommend this office!


    Autumn C.

  • The Doctor is very good. I felt on this visit he seemed rushed. I had questions to ask him but he was already with another patient. I still do not know if my eyes are the same , worse, or better.


    Howard B.

Testimonials


My eight year old daughter was terrified to go to the eye doctor for fear of her eyes being dilated. The doctor was SO KID friendly! He immediately made her comfortable by engaging her in conversation. It was a geat experience.


Joya B.

Dr. Garbus spent an amazing amount of time to solve my very complicated visual problems. Over the years he has continually achieved results beyond what others felt possible. He is always up to date on the latest science. He is great!


Dolores K.

Family Vision Care Valencia makes it so easy. Staff is knows what they are doing and Dr. Garbus is thorough and kept me well informed during the exam.


Kristy B.

I have been coming to Family Vision Center for almost 20 years. Dr. Garbus has been able to help my vision when other doctors could not. Now my kids see him as well. I highly recommend this office!


Autumn C.

The Doctor is very good. I felt on this visit he seemed rushed. I had questions to ask him but he was already with another patient. I still do not know if my eyes are the same , worse, or better.


Howard B.

All the staff is friendly, helpful and knowledgeable, and has been for all the years I have been going there.


Mary Ann H.
1 2 3 13

Blog

jana-muller-mi0zNl9ce6M-unsplash

Understanding Amniotic Membrane in Eye Care

Are you experiencing severe dryness, corneal ulcers, or irritation in your eyes? Are you looking for an effective treatment that can help you alleviate your pain and heal your cornea properly? If yes, then you might be interested in learning about amniotic membranes in eye care. In this blog post, we will discuss what amniotic […]

Read More
DSC_2190

How Does Vision Therapy Improve Reading Ability?

According to the American Optometric Association, approximately 80% of what a child learns in school is acquired through vision, and vision problems can significantly impact academic performance. As a developmental optometrist, has treated many students who struggle to learn how to read due to vision problems. In this blog, we will explore how vision therapy […]

Read More
close-up-of-an-adult-man-checking-eye-redness-in-f-HQYT3EJ

What Causes Bloodshot Eyes? Understanding the Causes and Treatments

Bloodshot eyes can be alarming, but they are not always a cause for concern. In this blog, we will discuss the common causes of bloodshot eyes, how to treat them, and when to seek medical attention. We will also provide some helpful tips for preventing bloodshot eyes in the future. Understanding Subconjunctival Hemorrhage A subconjunctival […]

Read More
see all blogs

Contact Us To Amplify Your EyeCare

Amplify EyeCare Santa Clarita Logo

Working Hours

Monday - Friday
9am - 6pm

 Saturday
9am - 1pm

Sunday
Closed

Location
28089 Smyth Drive Santa Clarita, CA 91355
Fax
(661) 775-9627
Website Accessibility Policy
Safety protocols page
privacy policy
For Patients
appointment
Call Us
Referrals
Assessments
Amplify Eyecare Santa Clarita eyefile-adduserphone-handsetcalendar-fullarrow-uparrow-right linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram